| Year | Name | School | Division |
| 2024 | Anna Bolich | Eastern Washing University | I |
| 2024 | Autumn Bennett | Nicholls State University | I |
| 2024 | Keniya Cleveland | Washington State University | I |
| 2024 | Ashlee Kraft | Montana Technological University | NAIA |
| 2024 | Kiyana Faupula | San Jose State University | I |
| 2024 | Franchesca Martins | University of Providence | NAIA |
| 2024 | Katherine Gee | Saint Mary's College of California | I |
| 2024 | Emma Daugherty | Texas A&M University - Kingsville | II |
| 2023 | Nellie Stevenson | Montana State | I |
| 2023 | Sydnee Rowe | UC-Riverside | I |
| 2023 | Hannah Taylor | St. Mary's | I |
| 2023 | Carissa Chainey | McNeese State | I |
| 2023 | Ava Saiers | Adams State University | II |
| 2023 | Seriah McKinney | University of Minnesota- Crookston | II |
| 2023 | Sara Fandel | Indiana University of Pennsylvania | II |
| 2023 | Eliana Sheridan | William Jessup University | NAIA |
| 2022 | Courtney Oilar | Northern Arizona University | I |
| University of Utah | I | ||
| 2022 | Morgan Avrit | University of Southern Tennessee | II |
| 2022 | Callie Muniz | College of Idaho | NAIA |
| 2022 | Madison Steele | Lincoln Memorial University | II |
| 2022 | Taylor O'Reilly | Oklahoma Christian | II |
| 2022 | Jessica Hickle | McKendree University (Beach) | II |
| 2022 | Hanna Parisio | McKendree University (Beach) | II |
| 2022 | Michelle Ramirez | McKendree University (Beach) | II |
| 2021 | Madi Gray | University of Louisiana, Monroe (Beach) | I |
| 2021 | Sydney Gott | University of New Orleans | I |
| University of Hawaii, Hilo | II | ||
| 2021 | Mattea Wilson | Ottowa University-Arizona (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2021 | Madisen Trueblood | Bushnell University (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2021 | Emily Leal | William Jessup University | NAIA |
| 2020 | Kayla Joyce | Pepperdine University | I |
| 2020 | Natalie Thomas | Missouri State University | I |
| 2020 | Aurora Carnes | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi (Beach/Indoor) | I |
| 2020 | Mere Nagase | West Texas A&M University | II |
| 2020 | Lauren Ornbaun | Fresno Pacific University | II |
| 2020 | Maya Carle | Fort Lewis College | II |
| 2020 | Lauren Erickson | University of Saint Katherine (Indoor/Beach) | NAIA |
| 2020 | Jessica Schumann | Bethel College | NAIA |
| 2020 | Dannika Day | Bethel College | NAIA |
| 2020 | Cortney Blumenthal | Ottowa University-Arizona (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2020 | Delaney Gill | Arizona Christian University (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2019 | Madison Howard | Texas A&M-Corpus Christi | I |
| 2019 | Chloe Hampton | University of New Orleans (Indoor/Beach) | I |
| 2019 | Jada Barnes | South Dakota State | I |
| 2019 | Delilah Cardenas | University of Arkansas-Pine Bluff | I |
| 2019 | Shiann Bontrager | Auburn-Montgomery | II |
| 2019 | Jill Wright | Cameron University | II |
| 2019 | Arizona Webb | Tusculum University (Beach) | II |
| 2019 | Brandee Burton | Corban University (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2018 | Katie Mckay | University of Louisiana, Monroe (Indoor/Beach) | I |
| 2018 | Cyan Blackdeer | Southern Mississippi (Indoor/Beach) | I |
| 2018 | Michaela Ahlenslager | Marshall University | I |
| 2018 | Precious Helekahi | Concordia University | II |
| 2018 | Chelyn Williams | Holy Names | II |
| 2018 | Megan Gallion | Lees-Mcrea | II |
| 2018 | Allison Trutna | Lake Forest College | III |
| 2018 | Kyla Kincaid | Hope International (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2018 | Ramsey Weber | Ottowa University-Arizona (Beach) | NAIA |
| 2017 | Morgan Hughes | Boise State (Indoor/Beach) | I |
| St. Mary's (Indoor/Beach) | I | ||
| 2017 | Summer Verycryssen | Holy Names | II |
| San Jose State (Beach) | I | ||
| 2017 | Kimberley Austin | Eastern New Mexico | II |
| 2017 | Liz Rosenburg | Johnson & Wales | NAIA |
| 2017 | Haylee Coates | Culver-Stockton | NAIA |
| 2017 | Summer WIlliams | Holy Names | II |
| 2017 | Jessica Martinez | Central Arkansas (Beach) | I |
| 2016 | Mariah Diaz | Great Falls | NAIA |
| 2016 | Lexxy Southern | Southern Arkansas | II |
| 2016 | Justine Cota | Lewis-Clark | NAIA |
| 2016 | Bailey Zavala | Chowan | II |
| 2016 | Lia Herlosky | University of Nevada- Las Vegas | I |
| 2015 | Marinda Thomas | Northwest Nazarene | II |
| 2015 | Nina Holmes | Albany-SUNY | I |
| 2015 | Abbie Mikelson | Montana State, Billings | II |
| 2015 | Alana Watt | Eastern New Mexico | II |
| University of Tennesee-Martin | I | ||
| 2015 | Jessica Jackson | West Texas A&M University | II |
| 2015 | Stephanie Ovitz | Lewis-Clark | NAIA |
| 2014 | Elizabeth Volz | Simpson | NAIA |
| 2014 | Katelyn Johns | Holy Names | NAIA |
| 2013 | Marilyn Agae | Grand Canyon University | I |
| 2013 | Jannette Van Sickle | Holy Names | II |
| 2013 | Jessica Voyles | West Alabama | II |
| 2013 | Lindsey Ball | West Alabama | II |
| 2013 | Carolann Warren | Newbury | II |
| 2013 | Stacey Witt | University of Hawaii, Hilo | II |
| 2013 | Callie Aberle | University of Hawaii, Hilo | II |
| 2013 | Amber Hall | Cal State Eastbay | II |
| 2012 | Tara Usko | University of the District of Columbia | II |
| 2012 | Jovan SIsovic | Westminster | NAIA |
| 2012 | Julia Lynch | University of the District of Columbia | II |
| 2011 | Kimberly Naut | Idaho State | I |
| 2011 | Katy Batchelder | Dominican | II |
| 2011 | Kadie Miller | Southern Arkansas | II |
| 2011 | Bryanna Chavez | Montana State, Billings | II |
| 2011 | Megan Godsil | Southern Arkansas | II |
| 2010 | Chenoa Rossi-Childress | Eastern Washington | I |
| 2010 | Rebecca Pate | Southern Arkansas | II |
| 2010 | Sarah Corbett | Cameron University | II |
| 2010 | Stacey Main | Eastern New Mexico | II |
| 2009 | Katie Redman | University of Tennesee-Martin | I |
| 2009 | Cassie Mahaffey | Great Falls | NAIA |
| 2009 | Nancy Rodriguez | Texas A&M, International | II |
| 2009 | Sabrina Blajos | Great Falls | NAIA |
| 2007 | Amanda Sbragia | Texas Tech | I |
