| Year | Name | School | Division |
| 2023/24 | Figo Cheuk | Mount St. Mary's University | NCAA D1 |
| Jack Cook | University of Northwestern Ohio | NAIA | |
| Nathan Scargill | Concord University | NCAA D2 | |
| Justin Kapp | LSU - Alexandria | NAIA | |
| Connor Wood | Webber International University | NAIA | |
| Donovan Hernandez | Mid American Nazarene University | NAIA | |
| Noah Stanley | Linfield University | NCAA D3 | |
| Logan Reed | Southwestern Christian University | NAIA | |
| Callum McGuinness | Marian University | NAIA | |
| Gerog Manolov | Warner University | NAIA | |
| Toby Evans-Gilham | Concord University | NCAA D2 | |
| 2022/23 | Ben Calam | The College of Idaho | NAIA |
| Devonte Richards | University of Central Arkansas | NCAA D1 | |
| Tajio James | University of Central Arkansas | NCAA D1 | |
| Rhys Cooke McCormick | St. Thomas University | Canada | |
| Kieran Swason | Georgia Gwinnett University | NAIA | |
| Isacco Tomelleri | University of Charleston | NCAA D2 | |
| Luke Quinn | Biola University | NCAA D2 | |
| Luis Santos | Cal State University, Long Beach | Education | |
| 2021/22 | Wade Muttitt | St. Mary's College | NCAA D1 |
| Denilson Capilla | Cal State, East Bay | NCAA D2 | |
| Alex Saunders | Delta State University | NCAA D2 | |
| 2020/21 | COVID | ||
| 2019/20 | Michael Dairo | Marymount California University | NAIA |
| James Kinsella | Marymount California University | NAIA | |
| Jasiel Celis | Cal State, Chico | NCAA D2 | |
| Joe Scott | Long Island University | NCAA D1 | |
| Luis Bugarin | Cal State, Los Angeles | NCAA D2 | |
| 2018/19 | Mathias Saether | University of the Pacific | NCAA D1 |
| Callum Nevill | LSU Shreveport | NAIA | |
| Mitch McLeod | Benedictine University Mesa | NCAA D3 | |
| Danny Navarro | Simpson University | NAIA | |
| Pedro Delgudo Romo | Simpson University | NAIA | |
| 2017/18 | Luis Martinez | York College | NCAA D3 |
| Guido Battistini | McPherson College | NAIA | |
| Tom Kleywegt | McPherson College | NAIA | |
| Kyle Parish | Long Island University | NCAA D1 | |
| Tom Bentham | University of West Alabama | NCAA D2 | |
| Fedrico Zamarripa | University of the Southwest New Mexico | NAIA | |
| Juan Manuel Arias | University of the Southwest New Mexico | NAIA | |
| Santiago Pereyra | Wayland Baptist University | NAIA | |
| 2016/17 | Jamel Julien | Alderson Broaddus University | NCAA D2 |
| John Perez | Alderson Broaddus University | NCAA D2 | |
| Conrad Gooley | Concordia University Portland | NCAA D2 | |
| Charles Hopwood | Coker University | NCAA D2 | |
| Ryan Birchfield | Lipscomb University | NCAA D1 | |
| Argenis Torres | Cal State, East Bay | NCAA D2 | |
| Christopher Cervantes | University of La Verne | NCAA D3 | |
| Ryan Holland | Penn State University | NCAA D1 | |
| Jack Fulton | University of Mass Amherst | NCAA D1 | |
| Jordan Whitchurch | Delta State University | NCAA D2 | |
| 2015/16 | Robel Dent | Union University | NCAA D2 |
| Jonathon Tuks | Cincinnati Christian University | NAIA | |
| Ashley Walker | Delta State University | NCAA D2 | |
| Dylan Murray | Texas A&M University Texarkana | NAIA | |
| Zak McCarthy | Texas A&M University Texarkana | NAIA | |
| Tomas Lopez | Texas A&M University Texarkana | NAIA | |
| Dominic Docherty | Lynn University | NCAA D2 | |
| Petter Knoph | California Lutheran University | NCAA D3 | |
| Gavin Gillies | University of West Florida | NCAA D2 | |
| Jacob Farthing | Mississippi College | NCAA D2 | |
| Darryn Hlabangana | Wayland Baptist University | NAIA | |
| Jake Price | Point University | NAIA | |
| 2014/15 | Tom Cowling | West Texas A&M | NCAA D2 |
| Brent Pedlow | Wheeling Jesuit University | NCAA D2 | |
| Adam Williams | LSU Alexandria | NAIA | |
| Tom Murphy | University of Dubuque | NCAA D3 | |
| Dylan Saib | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA D2 | |
| Jamie Reid | Goshen University | NAIA | |
| 2013/14 | Jack Wainwright | Marymount California University | NAIA |
| Lee Conroy | Marymount California University | NAIA | |
| Oliver Hitch | Florida International University | NCAA D1 | |
| Seon Ripley | Seton Hill | NCAA D2 | |
| Joe O'Neil | Erskine College | NCAA D2 | |
| Anthony Santo | York College | NCAA D3 | |
| Daniel Martinez | St. Ambrose University | NAIA | |
| Jordan Gill | Union College | NAIA | |
| 2012/13 | Douglas Williams | McPherson College | NAIA |
| 2011/12 | Dinesh Prasad | Cal State, Stanislaus | NCAA D2 |
| Makenzie Luckas | Lesley University | NCAA D2 | |
| Antony Wakeford | Lyon College | NAIA | |
| Vijay Godhania | Montreat College | NAIA | |
| 2010/11 | Juan Garcia | McPherson College | NAIA |
| 2007/08 | Josh Garn | Academy of Art University | NCAA D2 |
| Kyle Mannschreck | Academy of Art University | NCAA D2 |
