| Year | Name | School | Division |
| 2023/24 | Selah Draper | Concordia University, Nebraska | NAIA |
| Audrey Garland | Shaw University | ||
| 2022/23 | Brooke Fininis | Trevecca Nazarene University | D2 |
| Katelyn Brandao | Our Lady of the Lake University | NAIA | |
| Cheyanna Burnett | Huston-Tilloston University | NAIA | |
| 2019/20 | Bella Robins | McPherson College | NAIA |
| Angelica Soto | Menlo College | NAIA | |
| Laura Dority | Utah Valley State | D1 | |
| Marina Mayorga | Cornell University | D1 | |
| Maggie Bosworth | University of North Dakota | D1 | |
| Brook O'Hagan | Weber International University | NAIA | |
| Sydney Guinto | University of Ozarks | D3 | |
| Ayana Weissenfluh | University of Missouri, St. Louis | D2 | |
| 2018/19 | Diali Baeza | Johnson & Wales University | D3 |
| Alyssa Castillo | LSU Shreveport | NAIA | |
| 2017/18 | Brittney Arellano | University of South Carolina Aiken | D2 |
| Mckay Leos | LSU of Alexandria | NAIA | |
| Vanessa Hamilton | William Penn University | NAIA | |
| Kara Campbell | Pacific University | D3 | |
| 2016/17 | Olajua Pedemonte | Point Park | NAIA |
| Jazzmyne Garcia | Reinhardt University | NAIA | |
| Bret Nevala | University of Wisconsin Parkside | D2 | |
| 2015/16 | Aubree Hayes | Union College | NAIA |
| Danielle Smith | New Mexico State University | D1 | |
| Sam Buchanan | Georgia Gwinnett College | NAIA | |
| Kelsey Ritchey | Georgia Gwinnett College | NAIA | |
| Matilda Bylund | Southeastern Louisiana University | D1 | |
| Makenzie Clark | St. Katerine's College | NAIA | |
| Megan Stow | Barry University | D2 | |
| Isabella Wilson | Point Park | NAIA | |
| Megan Hellmuth | West Liberty | D2 | |
| Hannah Fenn | Louisana Tech University | D1 | |
| 2014/15 | Shannell Mcdonnell | Barry University | D2 |
| Hillary Wall | Delta State University | D2 | |
| Ryann Abeyta | University of Dubuque | D3 | |
| Emith Smith | Lyon College | NAIA | |
| Hope Guinti-Vasquez | Notre Dame College | D2 | |
| Stacey Cavill | Northern University | D2 | |
| Sherifatu Sumaila | University of Maine Fort Kent | NAIA | |
| Josfine Leberger | Northern University | D2 | |
| 2013/14 | Kayla Irmen | Cardinal Stritch University | NAIA |
| Lavaree Chavez | William Jessup University | NAIA | |
| Leslie Raygoza | Southern Oregon University | NAIA | |
| Patricia Sylvester | York College | D3 | |
| 2012/13 | Korey Cline | CSU, Bakersfield | D1 |
| Kali Fallow | NYACK College | D2 | |
| Melissa Kalbfleish | Prairie View A & M University | D1 | |
| Shelby Moore | Prairie View A & M University | D1 | |
| Naomi Feltham | Montreat College | NAIA | |
| 2010/11 | Selina Leblue | Holy Names University | D2 |
| 2008/09 | Thaisa Moreno | Florida International University | D1 |
| 2007/08 | Mayara Bordin | Florida International University | D1 |
